Why Church Volunteer Background Checks Matter
Churches rely on volunteers to serve in children’s ministries, youth groups, worship teams, and community outreach. Volunteers bring life to a church — but they also carry responsibility.
Without church volunteer background checks, organizations risk exposing children, youth, and vulnerable adults to harm. A single missed record can lead to:
-
Legal liability for the church
-
Loss of trust among families
-
Damage to the church’s reputation
-
Most importantly, potential harm to a child
Today’s families expect churches to take child safety seriously. Conducting comprehensive volunteer background checks is one of the most visible ways to demonstrate that commitment.
The Parent’s Perspective: What Level of Due Diligence Do They Expect?
💡 Baseline Thought: What do the parents who trust you with their child expect your level of due diligence to be?
Parents assume their church is doing everything possible to protect children. Anything less than full diligence — including federal criminal searches — falls short of parental expectations.
If a parent discovered later that a church only did partial checks and something slipped through, their trust would be broken instantly. The baseline isn’t “what’s cheapest” — it’s what would make a parent feel safe.
What Should a Church Volunteer Background Check Include?
Not all background checks are created equal. Many churches think a “national database search” is enough — but it isn’t. Here’s what SecureSearch recommends for every staff member and volunteer:
1. Multi-State Criminal Record Database
Covers multiple jurisdictions and provides a broad overview of potential offenses. Must include all names and aliases.
2. National Sex Offender Registry
Ensures no volunteer with a history of sexual crimes slips through the cracks.
3. County Criminal or Statewide Repository
Covers the actual courthouses tied to where the volunteer has lived in the past 7 years. This step validates and supplements database searches.
4. Federal Criminal Court Search
Reveals serious offenses not found in county searches, such as:
-
Internet crimes against children
-
Human trafficking
-
Financial fraud
-
Large-scale drug crimes
5. Motor Vehicle Records (MVR)
Required for volunteers driving church vans, buses, or personal vehicles on behalf of the church.
Why Many Churches Miss Federal Criminal Checks
Many churches don’t order federal criminal searches because of budget constraints or misunderstandings about what “national” searches cover. The truth: without federal checks, churches may miss serious crimes that never appear in state or county records.
Federal searches are inexpensive compared to the cost of liability, lawsuits, or reputational damage. SecureSearch strongly recommends adding them to every volunteer background check.
Beyond Background Checks: Training Volunteers for Child Safety
Even the best screening cannot catch every risk. That’s why SecureSearch partners with our sister company, Safeguard from Abuse, to provide Child Abuse Prevention and Awareness Training.
This Power of Two approach gives churches both:
-
Background checks to screen out offenders
-
Training to recognize grooming, warning signs, and abuse behaviors
Together, they form a stronger safety net than background checks alone.
Best Practices for Church Volunteer Screening
To maximize protection:
-
Screen all volunteers, not just children’s ministry workers. Greeters, custodians, parking lot attendants, and worship team members all interact with children.
-
Re-screen volunteers every 1–2 years.
-
Use an online applicant portal for efficient, paperless processes.
-
Communicate openly with families about your screening and training programs — it builds trust.
How SecureSearch Helps
For over 20 years, SecureSearch has partnered with thousands of churches nationwide to:
-
Provide FCRA-compliant, paperless volunteer screening
-
Deliver results quickly, often within 1–2 business days
-
Offer seamless integrations with Church Management Systems (ChMS) like Rock RMS
-
Support churches with dedicated compliance-trained staff
-
Deliver abuse-prevention training through Safeguard from Abuse
Conclusion
Church volunteer background checks are not optional. They are a critical part of protecting children, youth, and your congregation. By including federal searches and layering in training, your church demonstrates due diligence and a true commitment to safety.